| Alderson-Broaddus College (Battlers) |  |  |  |
| Bethany College (Bisons) | | | |
| Charleston, University of (Golden Eagles) | | | |
| Concord University (Mountain Lions) | | | |
| Davis & Elkins College (Senators) | | | |
| Fairmont State College (Fighting Falcons) | | | |
| Glenville State College (Pioneers) | | | |
| Marshall University (Thundering Herd) | | | |
| Mountain State University (Cougars) | | | |
| Ohio Valley University (Fighting Scots) | | | |
| Salem International University (Tigers) | | | |
| Shepherd University (Rams) | | | |
| West Liberty State College (Hilltoppers) | | | |
| West Virginia State University (Yellow Jackets) | | | |
| West Virginia Wesleyan College (Bobcats) | | | |
| Wheeling Jesuit University (Cardinals) | | | |
