| Anderson University (Ravens) |  |  |  |
| Bethel College (Pilots) | | | |
| Butler University (Bulldogs) | | | |
| Calumet College of St. Joseph (Crimson Wave) | | | |
| Davenport University (Panthers) | | | |
| DePauw University (Tigers) | | | |
| Earlham College (Quakers) | | | |
| Evansville, University of (Purple Aces) | | | |
| Franklin College (Grizzlies) | | | |
| Goshen College (Maple Leafs) | | | |
| Grace College (Lancers) | | | |
| Hanover College (Panthers) | | | |
| Huntington University (Foresters) | | | |
| Indiana Tech (Warriors) | | | |
| Indiana University (Hoosiers) | | | |
| Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (Jaguars) | | | |
| Indiana University?Purdue University Fort Wayne (Mastodons) | | | |
| Indiana Wesleyan University (Wildcats) | | | |
| Indianapolis, University of (Greyhounds) | | | |
| Manchester College (Spartans) | | | |
| Marian College - Indianapolis (Knights) | | | |
| Notre Dame, University of (Fighting Irish) | | | |
| Oakland City University (Oaks) | | | |
| Rose-Hulman Institute of Technology (Engineers) | | | |
| Saint Francis, University of (Cougars) | | | |
| Saint Joseph's College (Pumas) | | | |
| Southern Indiana, University of (Screaming Eagles) | | | |
| Taylor University - Fort Wayne (Falcons) | | | |
| Taylor University - Upland (Trojans) | | | |
| Tri-State University (Thunder) | | | |
| Valparaiso University (Crusaders) | | | |
| Wabash College (Little Giants) | | | |
