| Akron, University of (Zips) |  |  |  |
| Ashland University (Eagles) | | | |
| Baldwin-Wallace College (Yellow Jackets) | | | |
| Bluffton University (Beavers) | | | |
| Bowling Green State University (Falcons) | | | |
| Capital University (Crusaders) | | | |
| Case Western Reserve University (Spartans) | | | |
| Cedarville University (Yellow Jackets) | | | |
| Central State University (Marauders) | | | |
| Cincinnati, University of (Bearcats) | | | |
| Dayton, University of (Flyers) | | | |
| Defiance College (Yellow Jackets) | | | |
| Denison University (Big Red) | | | |
| Findlay, University of (Oilers) | | | |
| Heidelberg College (Berg) | | | |
| Hiram College (Terriers) | | | |
| John Carroll University (Blue Streaks) | | | |
| Kent State University (Golden Flashes) | | | |
| Kenyon College (Lords) | | | |
| Malone College (Pioneers) | | | |
| Marietta College (Pioneers) | | | |
| Miami University of Ohio (Red Hawks) | | | |
| Mount St. Joseph, College of (Lions) | | | |
| Mount Union College (Purple Raiders) | | | |
| Muskingum College (Fighting Muskies) | | | |
| Notre Dame College (Falcons) | | | |
| Oberlin College (Yeomen) | | | |
| Ohio Northern University (Polar Bears) | | | |
| Ohio State University (Buckeyes) | | | |
| Ohio University (Bobcats) | | | |
| Ohio Wesleyan University (Battling Bishops) | | | |
| Otterbein College (Cardinals) | | | |
| Rio Grande, University of (Redmen) | | | |
| Tiffin University (Dragons) | | | |
| Toledo, Univeristy of (Rockets) | | | |
| Wilmington College (Quakers) | | | |
| Wittenberg University (Tigers) | | | |
| Wooster, College of (Fighting Scots) | | | |
| Wright State University (Raiders) | | | |
| Xavier University (Musketeers) | | | |
| Youngstown State University (Penguins) | | | |
